Red Dead Redemption 2, winner of over 175 Game of the Year Awards, is Rockstar Games epic cowboy tale following outlaw Arthur Morgan and the infamous Van der Linde gang as they evade capture across America at the dawn of the modern age. At Player Opinion, we’ve primed our guns and saddled up to explore a fictionalized representation of the United States in 1899. What we discovered was a rich, vibrant world brimming with danger and intrigue.


Red Dead Redemption 2 Game Review


Gameplay Experience: 21/25

From the beginning, within the tutorial area nestled within snowy mountains, Red Dead Redemption 2 immerses players by gently introducing basic controls, laying the groundwork for the adventure ahead. Learning the ropes feels intuitive, yet mastering the complexities of the game proves to be a rewarding challenge. Whether engaged in thrilling showdowns with the law or epic and daring escapes, the gameplay strikes a delicate balance between enjoyment and difficulty. As decisions shape interactions with NPCs, the world around you reacts dynamically, though at times, the impact may feel somewhat constrained by the overarching narrative. Nevertheless, the game’s progression system ensures a sense of accomplishment, keeping players engrossed in Arthur Morgan’s journey. We found ourselves particularly drawn to the joys of hunting and crafting, activities that added depth to our experience.

Presentation & Immersion: 22/25

Red Dead Redemption 2 unfolds within a visually striking world meticulously crafted to captivate players at every turn. Each area explored offers a unique allure, drawing players into immersive roleplay experiences. We found ourselves attracted to the finer details, such as swapping out clothing to match the surroundings, enhancing our sense of immersion. The rich sound quality further elevates the overall aesthetic, adding depth to every experience. The unobtrusive HUD, reminiscent of Rockstar Games’ other titles, seamlessly integrates into the gameplay. Despite the polished storyline, our ability to predict certain plot elements didn’t diminish our experience but rather influenced our approach to the game. We found ourselves reluctant to progress further, opting instead to embrace the life of an outlaw on the road, savoring every moment of our journey.

Design & Technical: 22/25

With its exceptional quality, Red Dead Redemption 2 sets a benchmark that developers should strive to achieve. Rockstar Games’ commitment to crafting an outstanding product is evident throughout. Taking the time to refine every aspect has resulted in a game that not only stands out for its richness and diversity but also adheres to impeccable design standards. The game mechanics seamlessly complement the content, creating an impressive gaming experience. The AI’s intelligence and aggressiveness adds depth and enhanced realism to the gameplay, although occasional issues like sheriffs spawning abruptly from thin air can momentarily disrupt immersion. Nonetheless, our playthrough remained largely free of technical glitches, and the in-game settings provided ample customization options, ensuring a smooth and visually stunning gaming experience.

The Skinny About Red Dead Redemption 2

Final Considerations: 23/25

Red Dead Redemption 2 (Steam Link) offers an immensely satisfying experience, allowing players to live out their in-game lives in various roles, whether as a terrifying outlaw, a do-gooder anti-hero, or a simple hunter making a living in the fur trade. The game boasts an impressive replay value, surpassing most titles with its depth and variety, though marred slightly by the inclusion of microtransactions in online play. Nevertheless, the overall value far outweighs this flaw, making Red Dead Redemption 2 a worthwhile investment that promises extended periods of immersive gameplay. At Player Opinion, our team members all enjoyed vastly different gameplay experiences, each of us unanimously recommending this game. So, grab your boots, buckle up your holster, and prepare for an unforgettable experience. Highly recommended.

Think we got it wrong? Share your thoughts on Red Dead Redemption 2 by scoring the game on our Steam Review Template. Click Here to review and rate the game—Don’t forget copy to clipboard at the end of the review survey and paste it into your Steam reviews.

For players eager to engage with our community, you can find us on the Player Opinion Steam Community. For developers looking for feedback and exposure, check out our Steam Curator page. And for additional reviews, explore our dedicated Game Reviews section on our website.

Keep Us Alive!

Donate Today to Sustain Our Website's Operations and Fuel Fresh Content.